داستان کوتاه / روانشناختیShort Stories / Psychological
Putting Yourself on Trial
Prosecutor — Your present self Defendant — Your self from a few years ago Defense counsel — The Storyteller The charges Why did you stay with that person?
- 2 min read
- With video
Drag a page corner to turn it, or tap the page
Prosecutor — Your present self
Defendant — Your self from a few years ago
Defense counsel — The Storyteller
The charges
Why did you stay with that person?
Why did you accept that job?
Why didn’t you emigrate?
Why did you trust that person?
Why didn’t you leave sooner?
The hearing begins.
Prosecutor
“Couldn’t you see how it would end? Why didn’t you make the right choice?”
Defense counsel
“Mr. Prosecutor, the defendant genuinely could not see how it would end. You have seen the ending now.
In psychology, part of this is called hindsight bias.
Once we know how an event turned out, our minds reconstruct the past as though the outcome had been clear from the beginning.”
Prosecutor
“It was obvious that relationship would fail. It was obvious that person should not be trusted. They should have known.”
Defense counsel
“Sir, that is unfair. The question is not what we know today. The precise question is what the defendant knew at the time.
There is another error called outcome bias, judging a decision by its result.
If a decision turns out well, we say, ‘What a clever choice!’
If the same decision turns out badly, we say, ‘How stupid I was!’
Yet a decision may be entirely reasonable given the available information and still have a bad result. Conversely, a poor decision may turn out well through a little luck.”
Prosecutor
“Does that mean everything we did in the past was right?”
Defense counsel
“No. Sometimes the defendant really did make a mistake, ignore warning signs, act in haste, or choose badly. Even then, the purpose of regret should be learning, rather than lifelong punishment.”
Prosecutor
“People cannot simply make mistakes and then offer excuses.”
Defense counsel
“Please allow me to explain. An excuse means evading responsibility. The defendant accepts responsibility, makes amends wherever possible, and will use the lesson learned to make better choices in the future.
Your Honor, the defendant may make mistakes again. But from now on, they promise to choose more carefully, using the information available to them.”
Judge
“The court’s ruling is that you will not be punished this time, provided you retain the lesson and accept responsibility.
I hope I will not see you here again.”